FFIX: Worlds Apart Review, Disc 3

Hello, and welcome to my review/listening guide of the third disc of Final Fantasy IX: Worlds Apart, the remix album from the sonic wizards over at OverClocked ReMix!

I’ll be going through, track-by-track, and rating them on a 1-5 “Steiner Scale”, along with giving a few thoughts on why I rated them so.  You can listen along on SoundCloud or download the album yourself at ff9.ocremix.org!

A Rose in the Storm (Roses of May)
Natalya Zarraga feat. Seth Tallman

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Man.  I don’t think I’ve ever heard a bad “Roses of May” remix (and trust me, I have sought out many).  This mix is no exception – methodical, cathartic, with a nice little breakdown in the middle.  Nice use of harp.  Fuckin’ love harp.

Dig This Fossil (Fossil Roo)
Mazedude

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Y’know, out of the entire OST, Fossil Roo is one of the few I’m relatively “meh” on (it’s still Uematsu, so it is still, by definition, perfect… but you know what I mean).  This remix is definitely an interesting take, but it doesn’t really have the “wow” factor, nor does it make me look at the original song in a new way.  Still good enough for three Steiners, though.

Rally-ho! (Conde Petit)
Moomba feat. Fishy

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Dude.  Fishy rules.  I don’t look at the artists before I write these, but color me unsurprised that he (along with Moomba) took this remix and kicked its ass.  I thought I was going to fall asleep in the beginning, but they came back strong with some grade-A remixing starting about a minute in.

Fixations (Before the Altar)
RiverSound

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

LOVED IT.  Made me feel like I was at the (fake?) wedding in Conde Petit.  Great take on a song which, had they fucked it up, I would’ve been quite saddened indeed.  This one tugs at the nostalgic heartstrings.

Blakk Majik (Black Mage Village)
Brandon Strader, Jeff Ball

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Another song that, while well-executed, doesn’t seem to allow the true tone of the original song to shine through.

OH WAIT WUBUBUUWBUWUWUWUUBUBBIIES

+1 for dubby-wubbies.  They’re used to great effect, adding a layer of quirkiness that would have been lost had they gone with the more-aggressive guitar sound for the whole song.

+1 for having a Wicker Man reference.  WELP, I started this review at a 3, now it’s a 5.  Whoops.

I Am Gonna Stop Eventually (Unforgettable Sorrow)
Brandon Strader

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Utterly fantastic.  It really packs that “I just realized that I’m going to die one day” emotional punch.  Very sad, as it should be.

Plus, I’m a sucker for solo piano.  Sue me.

I’ll Always Be There (Eiko’s Theme)
Flexstyle

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Aside from the creepy whispers that sound more serial killer-y than like friendly reassurance, I thought this was a great remix.  Relatively light and bouncy, but with a tone of sadness, just like the character.  Flexstyle did a great job.  Highly recommended.

Iifa, the Super Tree of Death (Iifa, the Ancient Tree of Life)
ch4rl33

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

You can tell that this one’s by ch4rl33 immediately – sounds just like Knight-wit.  And, if you remember my review of that remix, that’s not a bad thing.

ch4rl33 does a great job of keeping the foreboding of the Iifa Tree, while adding his own dubby-wubby, constantly-morphing flavor to the music.  Another ch4rl33 remix, another 5/5 on my board.

Assassimander (Amarant’s Theme)
ch4rl33

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

OH NO, CH4RL33 GOT SOMETHING LESS THAN A FIVE!  GASP!

Don’t get me wrong – Assassimander.  In fact, the more I listen to it, the more it grows on me; hell, it might be a five in my book sometime soon.  I don’t think it carries the same glorious epicene that his previous two offerings provide, however.  It may look like I just give out fives willy-nilly, and sometimes I do, but I can be picky; I expect a lot from ch4rl33 now, and with that comes higher expectations.  Four out of five.

Four Score and Six-Eight (Tetra Master)
djpretzel

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Speaking of high expectations, I have them for djpretzel.  On a lesser album, perhaps I’d give this a four, but surrounded by the other stellar offerings, “Four Score and Six-Eight” musters no more than a three.  It’s definitely good; it’s definitely worth multiple listens; it’s not as good as many of the other songs on this album.

Miles and Miles Away (Esto Gaza)
XPRTNovice

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Man.  After my FFVI reviews, if you had told me that XPRTNovice wouldn’t get a 5/5 on this album, I would’ve said you were crazy.  But, hey, here we are.

This remix was quite close, actually – I looooooove smooth jazz, and this shit is smooth as a baby’s bottom wrapped in silk and dipped into a vat of liquid velvet.  Unfortunately, it didn’t have the “wow” factor; it never blew me away.  It worked great with the tone of Esto Gaza, but it’s squarely in the 4/5 range.

When Love Must Be Saved (Broken Spell, Healed Hearts)
Bluelighter

steiner fullsteiner full

It took a few minutes, but this remix came into its own… eventually.  Kinda.  Before the halfway point, this thing was headed straight for Onesville.  Honestly, I was just bored to tears.  It picks up a bit towards the end, however, and earns a bump in my rating.  Nothing special, but okay.

The Final Melody (Melodies of Life)
Jovette Rivera feat. ISAO

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

There are a few things you need to know about me: one, I’ve been looking forward to this album for years; two, the FFIX OST is quite possibly my favorite musical piece of all time; three, if you fuck up a remix of Melodies of Life, there will be hell to pay.

Luckily, Jovette Rivera knocks it out of the park, yo.  5/5.  Listen.  Love.  Listen again.  Love more.  Repeat.

Through Sun-drenched Skies (Aboard the Hilda Garde)
Archangel

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

Dude, Archangel is really fucking good.  The whimsy and glory of the original song is balanced and mirrored perfectly in this remix, while the artist definitely makes it their own.  That dude with all the umlauts in his name from Disc 1 may just have a competition in the MVP discussion for this album.

Bibliotheca ~ Dreamer in the Library (Daguerreo, the Hermit’s Library)
katethegreat19, Chaeley

steiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner fullsteiner full

So remember that time (read: those many, many times) I called katethegreat19’s voice gorgeous?  Yeah, well, it is.  And it remains so throughout this song.  The music is perfect for Daguerreo, one of my personal favorite locations in the entire game.  A fuckin’ library city thing built into a mountain?  How fuckin’ cool is that?

Anyway, yeah, five.  A fantastic run of songs to end the third of four discs.

4 Replies to “FFIX: Worlds Apart Review, Disc 3”

  1. Thanks for the review of each track on the disc. I think it’s neat that you took the time to do that and especially used the Steiner scale! I was hoping there would be more discussion of the album out there on the web, but I was hard pressed to find any that discussed it on a track-by-track basis.

    I have to say, though, that I’m sadly in disagreement on the remix of “Melodies of Life” on this disc. While the overall composition of the mix isn’t necessarily bad (particularly once the dance beat kicks in), the audio fidelity is where I frown upon it.

    As a definitive track from the game with so much recognition, I find it hard to believe there wasn’t someone on the team who was willing to step forward and do a fully-realized instrumental version; especially after following a number of tracks that were knocked out of the ballpark, this one stuck out as soon as it started. Same with the one that follows: as someone who plays flute and trumpet, those fake synth versions always kill it for me.

    There are so many other tracks on the album that use top notch synths and real instruments, and the fact that the synths on this track sound a bit lifeless just doesn’t do the piece justice. I’d be led to believe this was a track submitted to OCRemix back in 2005 when instrument packs weren’t as good moreso than I would believe it was created within the past 5 years.

    Still, the fact that the project was offered to the public for free offers little room for complaints, but I’m just a bit sad that on such a huge compilation that I walked away feeling letdown on one of the tracks I looked forward to hearing the most. These albums are always a mixed bag, so there’s inevitably going to be tracks not everyone cares for, I guess. I’m just glad they didn’t turn “Melodies of Life” into a wub wub dubstep version.

    Thanks again for the write-ups!

    1. Fantastically detailed response! Thank you!

      Yeah, it would’ve been awesome to have a fully-instrumental version, for sure. That said, as someone who’s barely picked up an instrument, much less played one with any proficiency, sound fidelity is much harder for me to notice, haha.

      And yeah, when something like this is offered for free, it’s hard for me to knock it. That said, with the mixed-bag nature that comes along with a giant compilation, I was a big fan of this one (not just because I’m a FFIX fanboy… maybe). Do you have any OCR albums that you like in particular?

      Thanks again for the comment!

      1. Agreed. I love the OCRemix fan albums. It’s always so much fun to hear all the different ways musicians take on the tracks. This album had some amazing renditions from the FFIX world!

        I loved the FFVI and FFII albums they recently over the past year or so. I thought they handled those extremely well. It also helps that the FFII music library was smaller than most other entries in the series, so there was room to be more critical of the entries rather than FFIX which has such an expansive soundtrack to choose from.

        One of my all-time favorite OCRemix albums was the FFV fan album Final Fantasy V: The Fabled Warriors ~I. WIND~. They applied musical stylings to each of the job titles associated with the wind crystal (Ex. “Theme of Black Mage,” “Theme of Blue Mage,” etc.) and even some character themes like Bartz and Exdeath.

        Nice blog you have here, by the way! *thumbs up*

Leave a Reply